Monday, September 11, 2006




You Can't Always Get What You Want...


....and sadly, sometimes, even if you try, you can't get what you need. What a day I've had. We started our new observations today at L. elementary school in the inner valley. I want to say inner city, but it's really the valley. However, it might as well be the inner city. The middle school we were at last week is only about two and half (fairly long) blocks away and as bad as that was, this elementary school is a thousand times worse. I feel like today was one of those seminal days that changes you forever. S. Middle School is like Beverly Hills compared to this K-5 school. The neighborhood goes from bad to really, really fucking scary in only 3 blocks. I parked on a busy street, but was still paranoid my car wouldn't be there when we were let out. There's absolutely no parking in the parking lot. The cars are stacked three and four high. The neighborhood is beyond poor. It is the very image of poverty, hopelessness, fear. It's a densely populated area, and the school is impacted with about 1200 students. About 98% are Hispanic and 100% are on both Federally funded breakfast and lunch programs.

According to our site manager, this place is the safest place the students will be in all day. This food is probably the most food, and the best food, they'll get all day. Most students come from immigrant parents. Many are agrarian workers. The site manager said that on average, the parents were only educated up until the 6th grade - maybe even less for the women. So not only do they not speak English, many of them are semi-literate or just completely illiterate.

Many children live with several other families in one room in one apartment. Sometimes they have no permanent address. Some kids live in a car. This is one of the few schools that has both a full-time psychologist on staff AND a psychiatric social worker. The problems at home for these kids are monumental. Divorces, abuse, alcoholism, drug abuse, incest, violence - and bad parenting...whcih isn't a crime but should be. The nurse at the school has the biggest job of any school nurse I've ever seen. She not only treats cuts and bruises, she gets the students glasses if they need them, medical care...even handing out soap. I mean, these kids don't even have SOAP sometimes! I took one sick little girl to the bathroom (she was a first grader I was observing - oh please don't let me get sick!) and she didn't even know how to wash her hands properly. So I gently asked her to use soap and explained to her why she should do that. Her name is Jessica and she was so sweet.

I have been placed in a first grade class all this week. I have to say, the teacher is really short, blunt and abrasive with these kids. She's not a bad teacher it seems; her style just grates on me. Many of these kids are very bright, although almost all of them come to kindergarten speaking no English. Yet these kids all spoke English pretty well. I could not stop thinking about the kindergarten class I worked with earlier this year and how much those kids have - not even in terms of material goods, but in terms of a place to live, and parents who are able to take good care of them.

These parents are at the bottom of Maslow's hierarchy of needs. They are in total survival mode. One mother keeps bringing her daughter to first grade an hour late every day. The teachers usually need translators to talk with the parents. Many parents don't care; there are a rare few that do.

Regardless of how I feel about their parents coming to this country as illegal immigrants (somehow I get branded as racist for stating a fact) I do know that all they want is a better life for themselves, and possibly more importantly for their children. Most, if not all of these children have been born here, so they are U.S. citizens. Sadly they move around a lot, so the school has a very transient population of students. I fear the U.S. will simply become like Mexico one day. There will be two classes of people. The very rich and the very, very poor.

I will say they had a beautiful, colourful library with tons of nice, new books. I was so happy to see that. The school itself is quite old. The bathrooms were filthy. I thought I could handle it. I think of that cliched line, "You can't handle the truth!" No. I was stunned. It's one thing to hear about poverty in the abstract. It's one thing to drive through a poverty-stricken neighborhood or see the occasional begger. It's an entirely different thing altogether to know how these children live, and see them up close.

I was introduced as Ms. D, because my last name is a bitch to say. They all said "Hi Ms. D!" They were writing a sentence or two on the story of Goldilocks and the Three Bears. Some wrote beautifully. One student should've been held back in kindergarten according to the teacher because he can't write at all. But for some reason he wasn't held back. This is why we have people at the college level who can't read and write. His mother didn't want him held back. The principal wouldn't back up the teacher. It's fucked. I walked around, said hello to each student and complimented their writings and/or drawings. They're sweet - they're just 6 years old. A lot of them seemed fascinated by me for some reason.

In other news, Fletcher abused her cone-free privileges and licked herself so hard it looked like she had internal bleeding. I called the vet from school and they told me to bring her in. So I missed the first class meeting of Educational Psychology. Thank God the professor was understanding. But it put so much pressure on me to miss that meeting. You get a feel for how the class is going to be in the first meeting. Although my friend P. will tell me about it and give me her notes, it's not the same as being there. I fucking NEW I was going to miss something due to this cat. I feel like even if I am sick and DYING I have to attend every class session no matter what. And little kids are always sick. I remember only too well how sick the kids at WR got me last spring.

At least they took Fletcher's stitches out. But that head cone is back on and back on for another week. I HAVE HAD IT with this cat saga. It's not her fault. But I knew in my heart I'd miss a class or an observation because of her somehow. I guess it was my own stupidity in freeing her from the cone.

Driving from the elementary school to our college for class, my friend P. said sarcastically, "We can't educate the Mexicans. Who will clean our houses?" Sadly I think a lot of people feel this way. But these kids do deserve an education. I just don't know if I have it in me to give it to them. God help me, but I don't know that I could do it. That makes me feel sad and ashamed. One thing I will always feel from now on, in a way that is completely different, is grateful for my upbringing. Grateful to the Fates, luck, whatever that I had two loving parents who provided me with a healthy, wonderful childhood for the most part. You think you have problems...then you go to a place like this. And suddenly, you have no problems at all.

9 comments:

General Catz said...

Interesting blog. We have a lot of similar schools here. Unfortunately, a lot of kids get pulled out to work to support the family. But a lot do stay in, and hopefully that will serve them well in the future. Everyone deserves a chance.

Whether you like U2 or not, there is a line from a song in their last album that is very sad but true:

"Where you live should not decide whether you live or whether you die."

Centuryhouse said...

I like that U2 lyric too. Some of the new songs didn't hit me at first, but on more listening to the lyrics there is some real depth & compassion there.

D - I'm sorry it's as bad as that. While not as bad, Dallas is taking a similar path to what you are describing.

When I see that kind of poverty, I wonder why they stay in it?

At 50 hours a week at minimum wage (most people at Burger King make more than that) would be $1100 a month. In mid sized cities like Tyler (where I used to live) you can rent a nice 3 bedroom house in a decent area for $400 a month.

Unless they're all single parents with lots of kids I don't see why they don't move to a lower cost town or state and get working. No one stays at minimum wage long unless they're a total idiot, and most unskilled entry level jobs start you out above minimum - but even at minimum they could feed their family and have a decent home & car. Restaurants & stores seem to have no problem hiring people that speak no English.

With health problems and no savings or credit after my divorce, I went from living out of a car to having a decent apartment in just a couple of months. It can be done.

It's a shame to see so many lives in that condition. I hope we find a way to resolve that, because the extreme poor in this country are growing leaps and bounds as they pour accross the border illegaly. Unless we want a society with a permanent uneducated & unskilled underclass, we'd better find a way to fix it.

The resentment of being an underclass among a relatively more successful & more afluent people will create tensions that will eventually explode.

veleska1970 said...

"heartbreaking" is an understatement. "shameful" doesn't do justice, either.

you're a saint, denise. i really mean that.

i will have to take centryhouse's word for it about this location~~i haven't been up here long enough to know. but i DO know that where i come from, the schools in new orleans have consistently, year after year, ranked as one of the lowest in the nation. the "welfare" mentality down there that has prevailed for years has a lot to do with it. generations upon generations of people who don't have any direction (and don't wish to) in their lives.

eh....i'll probably piss somebody off, but i was born and raised down there, and i've seen it for 36 years. the truth's the truth's the truth!!!

Bimbo said...

QH~ Oh,no, everything's fine. We have No Child Left Behind, remember? That effective little program makes it entirely possible for us to run this all-important fucking war. See, if we just keep pissing off the rest of the world with our brutality and bullying, there might not be a US left when these kids are our age. So it all makes perfect sense to me. How you do not get in your car and bawl your eyes out for a good two hours before heading home to cry some more is beyond me. Good luck and I mean that sincerely.

Queen Hatshepsut said...

K-
Funny you should say that...today I cried all the way home. Not because of the kids, but because of the NIGHTMARE that is their teacher. I HATE this woman and I've spent a total of 6 hours with her. She ought to be tarred and feathered for the nasty, blunt, rude, horrible way she treats these kids. As if they don't have enough problems. One little girl stood up during her lesson and just hugged me. So yes, I cried. I expect to cry again - the story of the children makes me sad, seeing the rotten teachers who even have jobs makes me want to vomit.

Queen Hatshepsut said...

Oh and Daniel - I agree with everything you said. I think a lot of Mexicans stay in L.A. because it's basically Mexico City North. It's home to them now. They have extended family here...and many aren't even educated enough to know how to move out of poverty. Also, why should they move out of it if the government hands them welfare checks all the time? There's no incentive to better yourself with SOME people when they prefer handouts. I admire greatly the ones who do try to better themselves.

Bimbo said...

QH~ Didn't mean to suggest that you didn't/wouldn't cry, hope it come off that way and should have been phrased better. I should have said: I admire your ability to function in such a fine mess instead of falling apart on the classroom floor. It's funny that as a kid the only thing I was concerned with inre teachers was getting a 'mean' one and how they treated me. From the adult perspective I'm more concerned with everyone getting a good one (both effective and nice). I had no idea what a bad teacher was as a kid. They were just people I didn't like and who didn't like me. Only as an adult am I seeing what truly shitzoid teachers are and are capable of. Ok, so I may have had some not-so-hot teachers here in grassy, green Connecticut, but not like that, man.

Centuryhouse said...

D - that's very touching about the little girl that gave you a hug. A very sad situtation that the teacher is that bad to/for them.

It seems like many of the worst school systems (due to budget maybe?) are missing the attitude that some successful companies have, which is to 'retain the best'. I think they often end up with the worst instead.

Imagine said...

Remember:
Not all Latinos are Mexicans ok?
I'm Mexican, born in Cordoba, Veracruz.
I'm literate in both English and Spanish though I came to the US (age 2) not speaking a lick of English. Like me, there are many other successful, educated, hard working latinos. Neither my family nor I have ever been on welfare and I became a US Citizen when that horrible Pete Wilson threatened to cut off my benefits despite the fact that I was/am a tax payer! Oh, yes honey, I helped vote that racist schmuck out of office!

I know you're not throwing us all in one same bag, I just felt I had to clarify some points: no matter what race, the poorest of the poor will suffer the most and there will be poor always.
Oh, and I do hope your friend P was kidding or I'll have to send some homeboys (probably from Venezuela) round her house for a true "cleaning".
Cecilia